Author: Daniel Mercer
Paul Schrader’s 1972 essay “Notes on Film Noir” remains one of the most widely cited and influential attempts to define and historicize the noir tradition. Rather than treat film noir as a classical genre with fixed conventions, Schrader described it as a movement or visual mode that emerged in American cinema during the 1940s and 1950s—shaped by postwar disillusionment, expressionist lighting, and existential themes.
Schrader argued that noir was not defined by content alone, but by tone: a fatalistic, morally ambiguous atmosphere dominated by shadows, rain-slick streets, and doomed protagonists. This emphasis on tone over structure marked a shift in genre theory and anticipated later arguments—such as those found in Such a Dark Mirror—that see noir as a haunting presence rather than a codified genre.
He identified key visual motifs (mirrors, venetian blinds, cigarette smoke), narrative structures (flashbacks, voiceovers), and character types (the anti-hero, the femme fatale) that recur across noir films but remain fluid and unstable. For Schrader, noir was “a style more than a genre,” reflecting a particular worldview rather than a formulaic pattern.
Schrader’s work opened the door for later theorists to treat noir as a critical lens through which to understand American ideology, masculinity, and desire. His essay also influenced filmmakers like Martin Scorsese, with whom Schrader collaborated on Taxi Driver and Raging Bull—films often cited as “neo-noir” in both tone and philosophy.
For a complementary analysis of film noir from a tonal and cultural perspective, see the essay "Alireza Kaveh and the Elusive Tone of Noir".
← Back to Articles